社区 › 音 响 论 坛 › 各位有没有可能尝试下？

shy888 发表于 2010-9-4 17:13:39

各位有没有可能尝试下？

James Randi Offers $1 Million If Audiophiles Can Prove $7250 Speaker Cables Are Better
如果有烧友能够证明$7K多的喇叭线（比普通的怪兽线）更好的话，詹姆斯●兰迪（教育基金会）将提供1百万美元奖金

Our rant about those $7,250 Pear Anjou speaker cables found its way to the James Randi Educational Foundation (JREF), and Randi offered $1 million to anyone who can prove those cables are any better than ordinary (and also overpriced) Monster Cables. Pointing out the absurd review by audiophile Dave Clark, who called the cables "danceable," Randi called it "hilarious and preposterous." He added that if the cables could do what their makers claimed, "they would be paranormal."

We see that the Pear Cable company is advertising a pair of 12-foot "Anjou" audio cables for $7,250; that's $302 a foot! And, as expected, "experts" were approached for their opinions on the performance of these wonders ... Well, we at the JREF are willing to be shown that these "no-compromise" cables perform better than, say, the equivalent Monster cables. While Pear rattles on about "capacitance," "inductance," "skin effect," "mechanical integrity" and "radio frequency interface," - all real qualities and concerns, and adored by the hi-fi nut-cases - we naively believe that a product should be judged by its actual performance, not by qualities that can only be perceived by attentive dogs or by hi-tech instrumentation. That said, we offer the JREF million-dollar prize to - for example - Dave Clark, Editor of the audio review publication Positive Feedback Online.

This is not Randi's first clash with audiophile reviewers who claim to hear differences between various pieces of exotic equipment. He promises a million dollars (which he has waiting in an account for them) if any can prove in double-blind scientific testing that their extraordinary claims are true. None have stepped up so far.

文中说到的这根线在这里：http://www.pearcable.com/sub_products_anjou_sc.htm

sentence 发表于 2010-9-4 17:21:44

什么叫证明？

shy888 发表于 2010-9-4 17:51:42

double-blind scientific testing.
所谓科学的盲测吧。即在测试者不知情的前提下测试两者的差异。:)

shy888 发表于 2010-9-4 18:24:06

原帖由 熄火 于 2010-9-4 17:21 发表 http://bbs.headphoneclub.com/images/common/back.gif
讨 赞助 ?

那不作数的，因为已经知道换过线了。:Q

kumochan 发表于 2010-9-4 18:39:15

這是變相打怪獸的廣告嘛?

pankiller 发表于 2010-9-4 18:40:43

shy888 发表于 2010-9-4 19:02:32

原帖由 kumochan 于 2010-9-4 18:39 发表 http://bbs.headphoneclub.com/images/common/back.gif
這是變相打怪獸的廣告嘛?

暂且不去说是不是为怪兽打广告（怪兽本身就是引起线材纷争的始作俑者），在毫无知情的情况下是否能明确听出两者的差异才是问题的根本。

kumochan 发表于 2010-9-4 19:08:19

原帖由 shy888 于 2010/9/4 19:02 发表 http://bbs.headphoneclub.com/images/common/back.gif


暂且不去说是不是为怪兽打广告（怪兽本身就是引起线材纷争的始作俑者），在毫无知情的情况下是否能明确听出两者的差异才是问题的根本。
電源線是太明顯不過樂.............喇叭綫應該也可以聽出................如果有電源線試聽..........我很想領些大米花花

shy888 发表于 2010-9-4 19:14:30

原帖由 kumochan 于 2010-9-4 19:08 发表 http://bbs.headphoneclub.com/images/common/back.gif

電源線是太明顯不過樂.............喇叭綫應該也可以聽出................如果有電源線試聽..........我很想領些大米花花


试过了？有人在你不知情的情况下给你换了一根电源线？:lol

kumochan 发表于 2010-9-4 19:20:18

原帖由 shy888 于 2010/9/4 19:14 发表 http://bbs.headphoneclub.com/images/common/back.gif



试过了？有人在你不知情的情况下给你换了一根电源线？:lol
等我找到LOLI...........就可以開始樂:lol

先秦 发表于 2010-9-4 19:22:07

俺还没用上喇叭线呢~层次差距啊

shy888 发表于 2010-9-4 20:01:40

原帖由 kumochan 于 2010-9-4 19:20 发表 http://bbs.headphoneclub.com/images/common/back.gif

等我找到LOLI...........就可以開始樂:lol


没有用的，君不知老烧们的宝贝，他人是碰都不能碰滴。:lol

kumochan 发表于 2010-9-4 20:06:31

原帖由 shy888 于 2010/9/4 20:01 发表 http://bbs.headphoneclub.com/images/common/back.gif



没有用的，君不知老烧们的宝贝，他人是碰都不能碰滴。:lol
這句屬實..........:handshake

shy888 发表于 2010-9-4 20:17:02

原帖由 熄火 于 2010-9-4 19:07 发表 http://bbs.headphoneclub.com/images/common/back.gif


侬吖算听Baruque 了

咋 粗头粗脑 :Q

看出来了伐？这位兰迪兄的意思是只要能听出$7K多的线更好，那他必然是具有超自然的功力（paranormal）。而他根本就不认为人类有这种能力。难道这样的言论不值得亲自去尝试一下吗？

chen0706 发表于 2010-9-4 21:50:49

这个测试好像因为Pear Cable没有提供线而不了了之了……

查看完整版本: 各位有没有可能尝试下？