很少有人欣赏到SCHNABEL贝钢的魅力，因为EMI 录音太垃圾：施大爷贝钢作品14CD发烧天碟

ypwangwei · 发表于 2012-8-21 18:24:14

感谢关注耳机俱乐部网站，注册后有更多权限。

您需要登录才可以下载或查看，没有账号？注册

x

DANTE 公司首版SCHNABEL 贝钢作品14CD （包括全部钢奏，钢协和变奏曲）。

这是一套最好的转录，比较的话，应该是 DANTE 》PEARL》NAXOS》EMI；达到了KEMPFF 50年代那套的录音水平；

描述一下，底噪全无，清透，明亮，饱满，丰厚，有润泽的阴影，展现出音色的丰富变化。

著名的PEARL版本与之比较，显得太亮太薄，没有厚度，失之表面化。

除了贝钢奏，钢协和变奏曲也是异常精彩，其中钢协五收录了两个版本。

我之所以会去找这套CD，是因为先前DANTE 公司 SCHBAEL SCHUBERT 4CD带来的的惊喜。把MONO制作成全无底噪
也许不难，但表现出丰富的音色变化就不是轻易之功了。强烈推荐DANTE 的作品！！

小白 · 发表于 2012-8-21 18:25:36

头像哪里拍的？

ypwangwei · 发表于 2012-8-21 18:33:21

PRAGUE.

jacob1990 · 发表于 2012-8-21 18:51:18

哇塞……很口水啊

暴君农 · 发表于 2012-8-21 18:59:14

马上就会见二手区的

莱纳 · 发表于 2012-8-21 19:23:50

白菜收过一套，没想竟然那么好？

ypwangwei · 发表于 2012-8-21 20:25:53

不是冤家不聚首，三个死老头子的贝钢奏开会了。

小白 · 发表于 2012-8-21 20:26:42

我打赌Dante的下场也是“当特”。

ypwangwei · 发表于 2012-8-21 20:27:12

哈，你以为你是章鱼啊。预言帝

偶就是不让这套出现在二手区。都三花聚顶了，再出是傻瓜。

ypwangwei · 发表于 2012-8-21 20:30:54

偶收片卖片是有标准的，一般一个作品的前三版本不出。

[ 本帖最后由 ypwangwei 于 2012-8-22 09:31 编辑 ]

708300 · 发表于 2012-8-21 20:59:48

DANTE的这个版本没听过，不敢妄加评论，不过珍珠的转录是SETH B. WINNER,他老人家的转录几乎没有败笔，我并不觉得薄亮，相反我觉得钢琴的声音很扎实。DANTE全无底躁？这样我反而会对他的低频和钢琴的音色产生怀疑了。

ypwangwei · 发表于 2012-8-21 21:42:58

Dante的低频非常出色。dante比pearl好不是我瞎说的，是老外对比后的评论。

ypwangwei · 发表于 2012-8-21 21:46:15

WOW, FINALLY....THE SCHNABEL DANTE SET ON AMAZON!!! But who knows for how long?!!!!

(This review is slightly modified from the one I wrote for the EMI set).

I had the EMI set and was completely satisfied with it for the longest time, until I wanted more Schnabel playing Beethoven. I did some research on the net and found a set on ebay that not only contained the complete Sonatas but had all the Concertos, Variations and Bagatelles that Schnabel did!

Let me tell you again. THE COMPLETE SOLO PIANO AND CONCERTO RECORDINGS OF BEETHOVEN BY SCHNABEL!!!

This was too good to be true, so I went out on a limb and ordered it. When I got it, I was holding gold my friend! 14 CD's in a slim case boxed set!

Okay, so I'm happy eh, but now for the transfer test...I compared the EMI transfers to the transfers this French label called DANTE did. Absolutely unbelievable! I'm listening to the Dante versions and I hear clarity, volume and depth, and hardly any hiss! I put on the EMI versions and I hear large hiss, muffled clarity and hardly any piano depth from the recordings. I was astounded! I immediately sold the EMI. Now, I also noticed that in the EMI, they don't always give each movement its own track, they sometimes link 2 movements together in 1 track (weird). But in the Dante they give each movement its own track and present the sonatas in complete chronological order, whereas in the EMI the order of the sonatas are mixed up a bit (which doesn't matter anyway). But I'm just letting you know. The Pearl transfers are clearer but with much surface noise and are somewhat better than EMI, and the Naxos are not bad too, except for the full hiss. but these are all available as singles pretty much right now. If you invested in all of these, you'd wind up with no more room in your collection!

If you want "THE" Schnabel set, get this DANTE 14 CD slim box set. I paid full price though, but it's been the best purchase I ever made in my life! (I would still recommend the EMI set to anybody, just because it's Schnabel playing Beethoven).

ENJOY!

708300 · 发表于 2012-8-21 22:17:07

看到老外的评价，PEARL的底躁是很大，但我觉得琴的声音很真实，EMI的没听过，NAXOS的比PEARL的琴声我觉得差好多，NAXOS走的是折中的路线，但牺牲部分低频的声音。

ypwangwei · 发表于 2012-8-21 22:36:12

不是说dante没一点底噪，但确实到了可以忽略不计的地步。牛！

		自动登录	找回密码
密码			注册

很少有人欣赏到SCHNABEL贝钢的魅力，因为EMI 录音太垃圾：施大爷贝钢作品14CD发烧天碟

感谢关注耳机俱乐部网站，注册后有更多权限。

回复 2# 的帖子

回复 5# 的帖子

回复 8# 的帖子

回复 1# 的帖子

回复 11# 的帖子

老外的评价。

回复 14# 的帖子

优秀版主奖

耳机鉴赏奖

社区建设奖